One Reddit user took to the subreddit to state that they had lost over $350 in Saint Denis after falling prey to one such criminal. Whenever other people aren’t trying to rob youThe blackwater massacre took the gang down spiral of bad, leading to the events of rdr2. He hangs out away from the rest of the crew. Players can hear Dutch complaining about his head injury several times during the remainder of the robbery, and his temper significantly worsens as the game progresses. Either it's the same deal, or it's like every other robbery in this game and I can solve it with a quick draw. This happened to me, first time playing the game in 2018, I just started chapter 2 but was having itchy feet and wanted to explore the map now that it was fully open after Colter. But allll the time when im up in the room, after i take the Money from the table i get a bounty and a bunch of policemans rushing the building. Got the bastards who robbed me in Saint Denis 💰 💰💰, I got robbed as Arthur and had to bite the bullet, so glad I got retaliation as John! Anyone else have to deal with. They only took $50 from me but I reloaded the last auto save anyway. KalebShmaleb 4 years ago #1. Almost a thousand fucking dollars, with no way to retaliate as soon as you walk into the alley. I could imagine a spaghetti western type game following the gang in the early days if these parts of the map were worked on. e hold up the gunsmith, opens the door and then knockout the guy at the top of the stairs) I am trying to do my gambler challenges and I have to play poker in saint denis. There’s an in game event, not sure what triggers it but a man and a woman are being robbed, the robber shoots the women dead and the man picks up her body. But i've been exploring and happened upon Saint Denis. Minor Spoiler - in Saint Denis I got robbed in an alleyway, loaded game and they disappeared . Those missions are missable, so you might have missed it, but I know I robbed it at least twice on my last playthrough, so you might get another chance if you hang around camp. got robbed in Saint Denis. 1 3. . 2 – Saint-Denis Gunsmith Robbery. This robbery is doable without getting a bounty on your head. r/reddeadredemption • Just got robbed $1400 in Saint Denis. 448K subscribers in the reddeadredemption2 community. Treasure Map 2: This map is found in the Saint Denis docks. Time to go do the ol’ $49,500 gold bar glitch to make myself feel better. Went to rob someone because I'm broke. . very special vibe of RDR2. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Saint Denis Robbery Encounter - YouTube 0:00 / 2:04 Red Dead Redemption 2 - Saint Denis Robbery Encounter Glori4n 3. • 2 yr. All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews. Another glitch happened yesterday where time didn't move forward unless it was forced to (like when I slept). Reply More posts you may like. ) So I guess killing people for a few dollars was worth it. Yada1728. Edited October 30, 2018 by Wildpoop. All because I tried to get on my horse. Red Dead 2 Saint Denis Gunsmith Side Business. /r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series. But when I do Saint Denis gunsmith robbery silently, without lawmen on my tail or wanted level, I do get hunted by bounty hunters. There’s actually three different alley mugging encounters in Saint Denis. find it by going to the unfinished train tracks north west of saint Denis to find a bunch of starving, tired Chinese immigrants laboring on the track. The game can glitch on some of those Robbery missions, like the ones in Valentine and Saint Denis. I had to open all 4 drawers. Denis robberies and pickpockets. Saint Denis Roof Access and for anyone who cares, i know i did, you can use the roof access points by the gunsmith to get into his secret robbery back terrace without doing it. Kuo Chao & Co. As an alternative to stealing the register, you might choose to rob the back room. Walk past the gunsmith and go straight to the backroom. So I tried to rob the secret poker area in the saint denis gunsmith and I got a tip from a homeless guy so I went to the gunsmith and robbed him but then I remembered that I had to actually discover the place first so as he was pulling out his gun I reloaded a save and when I went to look at the map for the gunsmith. This happened yesterday to me. The latest point in the game at which you can save for free roam without Arthur's TB affecting gameplay, is just before the Saint Denis bank robbery mission. By the end of it, I'd more than doubled that, but hey, I got a new hat and checked off a challenge. All I had to do was go back and complete it. The police officers within the department wear a uniform, consisting of a blue coat with black trousers and white gloves. You will find this robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 at the Rhodes Bank. All of the people in there should still be alive, I only knocked them out. Contents. UPDATE: RDR2 Locked Box. 1. It's every single trader I've visited. NOPE. is there any way I van get the money back from them? Nah you have to kill them when they draw on you, down the alley. r/reddeadredemption • Just got robbed $1400 in Saint Denis. Their horse kicked me in the head and killed me. “Hidin’ in plain sight” as Dutch always says. I. . Quite frustrating. First time I encountered this after 4 playthroughs. The second one they'll offer you goods for cheap (on the street right above the S in Denis) and you'll lose everything. " I think this is the problem, there is no “don’t lead an enemy back to camp” in Saint Denis. If you roll up to the gun shop in Saint Denis at night, there's usually a black Arabian posted up outside the gun store. Lucky for me I had just made a save reloaded it so got all. A man mugging a couple, the couple argues and the man kills the wife and runs off. I checked several times between mission tried coming morning, noon, evening and even during nighttime, For me it’s only the gunsmith, general store and doctor in Saint Denis. Her lifeless body flopped onto the ground after Arthur's strong grip took the life out of her. RDR2: Dutch's Failure In Saint Denis The Van Der Lindes eradicate the Braithewaite family and burn their home to the ground before leaving Lemoyne for Saint Denis. I woke up in the cemetary. I was riding towards the post office and a guy offered me some way to get quick money. It was by the tailor in Saint Denis. aim at shop owner then press d pad up to ask him to open hidden door. The problem is, is that the owner gets his gun out, the moment I try to rob him (with or without gun). UPDATE: RDR2 Locked Box. Hilariously, I kidnapped the main guy and tried to bring him out of town. Did you already know this? That's the. There are two main ways to discover the Gunsmith's backroom business: Overhear NPCs in St. Advertisement Coins. . Like the vast bulk of missions better players roll right through it with one eye closed. The other one is in the china town area, near the sign that says "liu hsing"-something. When you get knocked out, they're gone. Downside to the robbing aspect. • 1 yr. in saint denis, a lawmen will catch a thief, if u stop the lawman, the thief will say thank u but nothing else happens,, excerpt u get a bounty. 1. Several gang members lost their lives during the job, and when the survivors escaped by. Wait For Hosea’s Signal; 4 Rob The Bank. Join. I decided to free him to try to re-lasso him and deag him from my horse- this was outside of town- of course the damn st denis police miraculously showed up and screwed everything up. It appears that there are at least 4 of these types of events. And ended up in Bayou Nwa. It happened to me once. I just got robbed in saint denis by two guys how do I get my money backThe guy asked me to follow him into a alley and i assumed it was a robbery. Im having the same problem, it’s been closed ever since the start of chapter 3 and I am now at the end of chapter 4. Saint Denis gunsmith is one of the potential side business robberies in Red Dead Redemption 2. While I walking around Saint Denis at night looking for something I saw someone call me over and asked if I wanted to make some money. Knock on the security door and the guard will tell you to leave. I didn't know you could catch him. Kill them. There's a surprise in the wardrobe upstairs. There was $150 000 (approximately 4,5 million) on the ferry at Blackwater which likely came from Saint Denis. UPDATE: RDR2 Locked Box. 00 end up being worth it. 1 hour ago, jmcc84 said: He gets the disease on a Chapter 2 Strauss's "collect the debt" mission, from Mr. If you want to. Yes, Posses were a thing in the original RDR Multiplayer as well. Red Dead Redemption 2 Saint Denis Robbed in An Alleyway. We got it open! We paid $80AUD & this usually sells on eBay for $450-700! Never thought I'd own this :)Just got robbed $1400 in Saint Denis. Saint Denis is basically the antithesis of the Van der Linde gang ideals. 289. Around the south-east quarter of Saint Denis, you can find five messages scrawled on walls, each with a strictly vampiric theme. Here's a tip, just first, rob the place and knockout the owner, deal with the guard, then run up to the third floor, then get the money and run back, there will be a porch, the porch is connected to walls and roofs which you can escape assasins creed style, and stay out of sight and tada. A whole bunch of them awaited me with guns. I've already tried changing the API from vulkan to dx12 and vice versa, letting geforce. Hosea is killed, and Lenny is shot as soon as he's seen, both of them being unarmed at the moment they're killed. Arthur gets robbed in Saint Denis | Red Dead Redemption 2In Red Dead Redemption 2 there are four stores that you can rob. A variation of the event happens in the Rhodes Saloon. Called "Banking, the Old American Art," the gang is tasked with robbing Leymoyne National Bank in Saint Denis. Just got robbed in Saint Denis in front of Jade Dragon Restaurant . My plan was to rob him but then i got hit in the back by a bat and they robbed me instead i lost 990 out of my 3000$ R. In SP I usually ride my Arabians in St Denis as they are super agile. This happened to me too and I went looking for the culprit, but never saw him again. 4 km (5. Prerequisite: None. He lead me down an alley way and then I was knocked unconscious by one of his mates. Please tell me what you think of it! Sorry for any spelling errors. then you can follow him and steal the horse. I tried to get onto my horse in Saint Denis and accidentally grappled an old lady by the neck. It's the least dangerous encounter with the Lemoyne gang, as the thugs will be too occupied fleeing their crime. Saint Denis is filled with interesting people. I was taking a walk one fine evening when I heard a guy pssting me to go to him. So I gave a homeless drunk money in saint denis and he told me about the poker game above the gunsmith. Red Dead Redemption 2 NPC Robbery – How to Get Your Money. im a bit different but, i was getting shot at because of some 2 people and so i defused it and continued. Bronte knew the gang was one of criminals, and he had already set them up with the train station robbery. Instead some dude knocked me out from behind. opbrplayer4 • 2 yr. I made a save before speaking to the guy in the alley, because he looked suspicious. Here I am with the a new post about the saint denis bank incident with Hosea and Lenny. I was very surprised to discover the intricacy of the game's random encounters 30 minutes later when the Dr. Dan_rumble119 1 point 2 points 3 points 6 days ago . You will find this robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 at the Rhodes Bank. There's signage saying Hestia street both on the road going south off Milyonne Ave and West off Frontier St. Reply reply. I. Although the robbery starts off well, Pinkertons quickly arrive on the scene. Today I just noticed the task thing is still on my tasks page and not marked as finished. The first time I ever completed the Valentine robbery was immediately after I had knocked out the big dude in order to steal his Raccoon hat. I was pickpocketed going into the tailor in Saint Denis, within 2 feet of a cop. It was part of Dutch’s insanity exacerbated. led. Consequence. I was playing red dead redemption 2 and I entered a house and was greeted by a Overweight bald guy and a young woman. Suddenly, a random event blipped on my minimap, so I went and check it out. They track down Bronte and retrieve John's son, but Dutch insists on furthering the gang's involvement with Bronte in the hopes of getting enough money to escape and. It was so frustrating that once I got better at the game and weapons I would occasionally swing by St Denis and. Alright, I have taken a long break but then decided to get back into rdr2 scripting so this will be the first update of many to life of crime. I recently robbed the gun store's backroom in Saint Denis, and as I know it with the doctor in Valentine too, it should refresh. Everyone’s talking about their FAVOURITE places in rdr2, so let’s switch it up a bit. Superjaybo64 · 8/11/2021. Hey, it's Ray! Links to highlights found below - First time playthrough of Red Dead Redemption 2 continues on with episode 6!second robbery occurs in the city of Saint-Denis. . Quote from my brother playing RDR2 blind. There’s actually three different alley mugging encounters in Saint Denis. 27% 100%ing it. Denis was made annoying on purpose. Yeah I got robbed trying to go to the tailor and lost about $100 and got a little over $300 when I looted the guy. I have since edited his and labelled the road north of the house that hooks onto the end ot Milyonne Ave as Flavian St cause that one has no signage and there's not a single sign that says Flavian Street anywhere. Just got robbed $1400 in Saint Denis. 0. She gives him dutch and her, Jack, and John all walk. Just got robbed $1400 in Saint Denis. Posted November 21, 2019. Unlike most of the other towns, SD is highly Policed. [Red Dead Redemption 2 played on PC] Killable children mod used in this video 2. So some guy offered. After having been robbed like 4 times when I entered various stores in Saint Denis in my first play through it happened a fifth time now. One by the Chinese gunsmith, one by the general store, and one north of the trapper. Haven't been around Saint Denis enough but I'm also hoping I can get some sweet revenge. r/reddeadredemption. Robbed in Saint Denis. You have to. First time I encountered this after 4 playthroughs. Jenny Davey And Mac all died. It is located 9. denis. We as outlaws would never be able to integrate in the city life and avoid the place as hard as possible. Denis where a couple gets robbed on the street, and if left unattended, a woman gets shot. 17 comments. Cholera. Red Dead Redemption 2Denis warning. Just saved Micah. Took the train to Saint Denis, got there at nighttime, and got that interaction. Red Dead Redemption 2 > General Discussions > Topic Details. Then I went back to Rhodes around 6 pm game time, “discovered” the gunsmith’s secret business, put on the bandanna, and initiated the robbery. led. PST-Dipsy • 5 yr. The Industrial Revolution has long since made its mark on American society, and the Civil War is still very fresh in living memory. However, you only need to rob one of them to complete the game in 100%. " (It has increased to $1 = $29. For some passive entertainment, players can head to the ornate theater and watch. 93% per year during this period. on the same boat here, went to get a nice fist fight with them fuckers but got robbed of 700$, now i'm at the exact same spot and the guys are just not here. Arthur meets Dutch and Lenny in an alley across from the trolley station. renanmiron. Was there a while as i was on my phone but the place was empty the whole time. Specifically, it is the gunsmith’s shop that will be robbed. Keep in mind, things here are much more expensive than they are in smaller towns like Rhodes and. Bank Robbery: Charles. 236 votes, 29 comments. But I guess that means its randomized. A lot of people have pointed out that his. I dont think you can find them. Been spending far more time around camp on this play through (number 4). Business, Economics, and Finance. Saint Denis gunsmith is one of the potential side business robberies in Red Dead Redemption 2. I shot them up as much as I could, but then got surrounded by cops and trapped. So some guy offered me a chance to get some quick money and then knocked me out in an alley. One is near the docks/probably near the trapper in st. It appears that there are at least 4 of these types of events. I just chased him til I caught him tbh. I have absolutely no reason to post about these types of stuff, but honestly I like getting my feelings out. So, I got robbed and pickpocketed in quick succession, and checked on here. I’ll head straight back if there is a chance of finding them though! I went immediately back and there was only a woman and man up on the balcony to the left when you go down the alley. Was riding on my horse when this guy who stood infront of an alley called me and said I could earn some money with him. When I re-watched this scene again yesterday, I thought Molly did talk to Milton, and she was the one who tipped him and Agent Ross about Dutch's plan for the Bank Robbery at Saint Denis prior to the start of that mission. The Mercies of Knowledge is a Stranger Mission Strand (Side Questline) in Red Dead Redemption 2. Shit I think this has turned into the first large negative feedback post to RDR2 I’ve seen on this sub. Subscribe. . 3. Some camp members will take you on special home robbery missions, so in these cases, simply follow their lead. Chapter 4. Denis bank robbery. r/reddeadredemption2. "Massive, massive quantities. It broke me, realizing that Molly somehow was responsible for Hosea's and Lenny's tragic deaths. Denis robberies and pickpockets. He said he had insight on a quick money grab but i had to follow him inside so he could show me. ago. Remember to cover your face with bandana before you enter the store. Remember to cover your face with bandana before you enter the store. Normally, if you press aim button slowly, you'll enter dead eye duel mode. My checklist still shows the task, but I go back and I cannot knock on the metal. . 63. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. Red Dead Redemption 2 > General Discussions > Topic Details. I got robbed in Saint Denis. Best way to do this is to rob a train. 0. I also assumed it would let me fight back. In terms of Saint Denis, let's look: Gang had just made contact with and attended a party at the invite of Angelo Bronte. It just doesn't make sense that the gang can't return to a small town in the West because of a ferry heist (which was atleast 6 months ago by that point), but are able to as easily waltz into a big city like Saint Denis on multiple occasions with no hassle after massacring half the police force AND robbing a state bank. Played this game at least a 6 times all the way through and never knew about this Poison Knife pamphlet in Saint Denis under the floorboard in this shack. It's the least dangerous encounter with the Lemoyne gang, as the thugs will be too occupied fleeing their crime. Posted by u/DanTheFireman - 2,231 votes and 187 commentsSo many potential properties to purchase under the new role of "Old West Slumlord", which you can get started with by purchasing the realtors map for 15 Gold, or the prestigious realtors' map for 30 Gold. 8 Sort by: Open comment sort options abrowe08 • 5 yr. Just got robbed $1k. There is no way you'll get that one back or at least I haven't yet. Head to the shop and enter it to go to the backroom. I looted the safe and everything. You can get your money back if you chase the guy and catch him and loot him. I'll try and put a picture up (fat guy and sister house) there is a photo when you walk in , inspect that it's there. ago. In this RDR2 video I walk you through one of the most perfect robberies in red dead redemption 2. Only the one north of the trapper allows you to get your money back by going back to the. 1. Yeah it's literal bullshit that this can happen, like fuck whoever made that crap, I knew I was going to be robbed but you force me to get knocked out and I can't even react it's such horseshit also I can't even find my money again too. $85 bucks. In Chapter 2 she just wants to get back at John. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online. r/reddeadredemption2. It was by the train track and across the street from the general store. I’ve done this, and I’ve robbed a side business before. It's because I canceled the Mary mission in Saint Denis during chapter 4. So some guy offered me a chance to get some quick money and then knocked me out in an alley. 10 Saint Denis City Hall Vandals This one is for those who like to play vigilante. I think a 2nd robbery is a glitch. If the player completes the mission as Arthur, Buell will be lost along with all the other horses owned by Arthur after the mission “Red Dead Redemption”. There’s actually three different alley mugging encounters in Saint Denis. I've tried investigating the back room like you should. 2. Music/Song from Red Dead Redemption 2 - Banking, The Old American Art | Saint Denis Bank Robbery Heist full extended version mission theme (recorded in the g. I love this game but I also hate this game. don't forget the gold nugget on the desk. So about 2 or 3 weeks ago I went around and found the 5 clues for the vampire and drew the little pentagram map in my journal, but I literally can't get him to spawn. #8. After killing Angelo Bronte in the mission "Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten," Dutch comes up with the plan to rob the bank in Saint Denis, which should give the entire group enough money to move to Tahiti and escape. She gives him dutch and her, Jack, and John all walk. As we know, after the deaths of Hosea and Lenny the rest of the gang attempts to escape Saint Denis after the robbery goes wrong. Happened to me lost thousands woke up in the graveyard other side of town. i got a worse one for ya. Instead, I got knocked out from behind, and woke up in the saint denis grave yard $1,200 poorer. Then some dude behind me bonked me on the head and then I woke up in the graveyard with about 300-400 bucks missing. It's just always closed, I've never been able to get in. As soon as we went down a alley way a guy knocked me out and i wake up far away with my hat gone and 600 dollars stolen from me. • 5 yr. The couple is the only NPC or set of NPC’s (besides the Saint Denis Stable owner) to own a Black Arabian in the whole game. So for those of you who know about Arthur's unfortunate demise in RDR2, you may be wondering when the best time to make a save for free roam is, prior to Arthur's tuberculosis. I thought that I might have a chance to fight back. So there are two. theblueraven 4 years ago #4. Also the door is not responding on the other side. hi guys. Researched it on Reddit and everyone is saying that the money is gone. If your quick the house is going to be beside your horse. Just checked everything in the area twice. Saint-Denis is the second most populated suburb of Paris (after Boulogne-Billancourt), with a population of 113,116 at the 2020 census. My favorite stealth mission in all of RDR2 is trying to sneak through saint Denis TO PAY YOUR BOUNTY FOR SAINT DENIS . 33 #10Lmfao also got robbed by those two. r/reddeadredemption. A lot of people have pointed out that his. TIL the founder of Blackwater married a 12 year old native American girl after killing her entire family, was best friends with an opossum which he eventually wore as a hat till his dying day, and was inspired to be a congressman after a drug and prostitute fueled binge in Saint Denis. Red Dead Redemption 2 Mugged in Saint Denis GodsPlanB 4 years ago #1 So this board has an archived thread saying you cant get your money back. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. A Train Robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 is similar to coach robberies. John however while actively killing and fighting off pinkertons, is only arrested. This Walkthrough shows how to complete these Stranger Missions in RDR2. The "cheap guns," one, where you're left on the beach, the "quick buck," one where you're left in the cemetery, the "little kids," one where you can actually defend. First 5 minutes in Saint Denis after it got unlocked, I had a random encounter with street urchins who fucking knocked me out and robbed me blind. Early Arabian. 57 in 2016, a difference of $27. I went on a hunt for those bastards after they stole my money and never found them. Themightyred92 Jan 13, 2020 @ 10:25am. #1 Eminem Jan 8, 2020 @ 4:55pm just walk away. There’s an illegal poker game happening inside the gunsmith’s shop in Saint Denis. If you wait until daytime or leave the area, it's gone. I followed them in and these guys came out, so I drew my pistols, killed all the adults, and no wanted. The shop of the gunsmith is the one to be robbed. Im not too far in the game. But, it’s possible that Micah wasn’t the rat before chapter 6. 35K views 11 months ago #rdr2 #gaming. Just north on the sidewalk was the guys getaway horse, which was this Black Arabian. This would mean that Micah was always a rat, but I think there's one event that he wasn't responsible for: the botched Saint Denis bank robbery. I think there are two different random encounters like this one in Saint Denis, where for one of them, you can recover your money, and for the other encounter, you lose your money permanently. This counts towards the challenge and you can complete it without losing honor at all. I got robbed by those kids and lost 2,000 dollars. if you being the bad guy and do not give a toss, then just shoot em dead and deal with the bounty and cops trying to kill you. I wanted to go back and kill them but they didn't show up when I loaded the save. Not when its 3 robbers and the other 2 were shooting me because i punched 1 of them while being robbed, i fire 1 shot and i got a bounty. So, I just got mugged at Saint Denis at night. A lively, 200-year-old melting-pot city where industry magnates, socialites, traders, sailors, workers, beggars, and thieves all live side by side. People in Strawberry and Saint Denis were injured. Basically think of R2 as multiple buttons because it actually cares how far you are pressing it. 75 bouny and it was ok. Arthur Morgan gets robbed on his way into the gun store in Saint Denis, and in this clip, here’s one way Arthur can handle getting robbed in Saint Denis in R. I'm just glad I immediately made a save knowing it's either a trap or a dishonorable deed. Gold Medal Requirements. i lost 1500$. The white dot was still up, so I went to check up on it, of sudden few more people jumps on me with revolver to my head, kid comes and takes 300 bucks from me and the the guy with revolver. ago I loaded my game from my last save, returned the the area, found the guy about to “rob” me and shot him in the face. Get in the Stagecoach /Drive to the Bank To begin the Banks Don't Rob Themselves. Red Dead Redemption 2. Hosea is sick with something (his constant coughing, possible lung cancer) and knows his time is comming. I got robbed in San Denis by a stranger and they stole $1300. Go to the back of his store and you’ll see a locked metal door. . Tbh I ended up fleeing with my bounty at 500 odd dollars and stayed in strawberry for a few days doing a few bounties and helping strangers to pay the bounty. You do not need to collect them in a specific order, but it seems. The plan is like this, Abigail and Hosea will create a diversion for the police, and then the rest of the group will rob the bank. I thought I would shoot them after drinking but I was thrown into a. I got robbed in Saint Denis, is there anyway to track the person down and get your money back or kill them? comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment bjarni19 • Additional comment actions. So I'm currently doing the Saint Denis bank robbing mission in chapter 4 and have a question about the quest involving the Saint Denis mayor. Go to the back of his store and you’ll see a locked metal door. Knock on it and this will unlock the option to rob the Saint Denis gunsmith side business. One by the Chinese gunsmith, one by the general store, and one north of the trapper. r/reddeadredemption. Advertisement Coins. I got robbed in San Denis by a stranger and they stole $1300 comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment FlamingoWang • Additional comment actions. If not it's a lesson learned. If he listened to Hosea, hit the bank at once, then vanished, the Pinkertons would have never caught on and they would be harvesting mango's in Tahiti (poor Arthur would have still died :( from TB).